Perhaps more has been said on the subject than is required.
I don't want to say anything about mourning and grief, about shock and loss for few, and voyeurism for many, about an impotent government machinery, treacherous neighbors or moles in the midst.
For one, I don't think the government - its intelligence and police departments are entirely to blame on detecting this one. Rahul Gandhi's statement may have been insensitive but not entirely untrue. And in any case, the BJP is a complete ass to go and stage protests over this and even stoop down to the ridiculous level of suggesting primary and secondary education for him. If the BJP thinks that the people of India entrust it to lead the country into a more peaceful and developing era, it is delusional – it may have forgotten Babri Masjid, but we haven't. Furthermore, we don't tend to recall all those times when danger is averted through vigilance and swift action. Search online and you will find at least a couple of these every month, many of them in the chronically troubled regions of our country. That is another sad truth – a majority of us wake up to terror once in every two years (barring the people who lose their family and friends for whom every day must be a struggle), but there is a significant number of people in this country who live like that constantly. So much so, that civilians are trained and armed by the government to fight such terror (Salwa Judum in Chhatisgarh being a controversial example).
No. The government within the sphere of its present defense mechanism and policy could not have done more. Of course, the fact that the proposal to create a body called the National Counter-Terrorism Center has been gathering dust since the time it was proposed in April 2010 by P Chidambaram, reflects an utter failure of the government to create new policy and redefine how India should battle terrorism.
I don't claim to know a lot, to be very intelligent or a supreme visionary. But I have had enough and I don't believe that the answer lies in knee-jerk reactions, or a change of government.
India needs a complete overhaul of its defense and counter-terrorism strategy. A new policy that will trickle down to the very grass-roots, affect you and me in its execution. Gone are the days when only the government and its military, police and intelligence departments could be expected to blow the winds of change. The enemy is attacking me and my family and if things are to change, we have to be equally involved in that change. Maybe take a few pointers from nations like Israel, who are surrounded by enemies on all borders and are still one of the most developed nations in the world with the highest life expectancy and usage of solar power. Israel is also the highest spender on defense as a proportion of its annual budget.
Yes, we could adopt a thing or two.
We need better border defense, better equipment for tracking invasions, more advanced technology and weaponry. Case in point - the high-tech boats that were purchased after December 2008 to patrol the seas are lying unused because of the huge amounts of petrol they require.
We need to be ruthless and perhaps inventive in cleansing our own territory of terrorist elements. Like cloud computing, we should enlist the support of civilians for doing this - encourage citizens to report suspicious activities and characters, which are then investigated thoroughly by the authorities (a thorough investigation does not mean giving every suspect the third degree - remote surveillance and background check should be enough to eliminate many of these suspects). We should give civilians easy access to the police for reporting any irregularities they encounter - like unattended bags, abandoned vehicles, etc. We should make that a way of life - I see a bag lying on the railway platform and if nobody comes forward to claim it, I call the police. There will be false alarms, but even one successful detection is enough to justify the manpower expense. Further more, we need CCTVs at railway stations, bus stations, airports, cinema theaters, crowded public places. And personnel manning these CCTVs at the HQs.
We need better infrastructure and disaster management. I read someplace that the CM of Maharashtra could not get in touch with the police commissioner after the blasts due to network jamming. Fire trucks, police, ambulances should be the first to reach ground zero, instead of the media.
Finally, to effectively execute all of these, we need more militarization in our people. Compulsory conscription for both males and females over eighteen years of age.Military service for all doctors and engineers even. A reserve army of trained civilians at all times, who can rush to the scene of attack and provide relief and rescue, or even combatant services till the time the police, army or the Black Cats arrive.
All this may sound radical and unsavory. All of these suggestions require huge levels of commitment from We, the people. We are a nation that loves our food, songs and Bollywood. But this new reality is a game changer. And the first step towards killing the enemy is to acknowledge that there is one in our midst, even now as I walk towards the bus-stop to go do my non-controversial job of selling soap. India is no longer living in peacetime. There is war underfoot.
7 comments:
Nice -share the same sentiments ,
but sadly we wont be able to curb this menace for sure, and this is irrespective of any party coming in power .
Reason –V simple –for all of political parties or systems or any other infrastructure –most of others things will always get priority over national security or national interest . Sometimes it might be Vote bank politics, might be ego, and might be greed might be self ambitions. Every other thing will come first –sadly that’s how we are –dates how our DNA has become – It is sad –but it is true –one has to be ruthless in pursuing national interest or security which wont happen in our case... unfortunate but true . We might improve operationally in tackling this but overall we will fail to tackle this.
i think a part of every city's tax revenue shud b ploughed back into enhancing security systems for tht city itself... and this entire thing shud b privatised n kept very transparent....
Interesting inputs. Perhaps, you need to publicize some of these ideas a little further.
Hey,
Good article. My thoughts.
- Agree that there are multiple issues are at policy, technology and readiness level
- Agree that change in government is not going to change a thing. BJP is ineffective and incapable of forming govt in Center at least for next 2 elections.
- We can not deny that despite all these limitations, there is a complete lack of intent and apathy towards acting against terrorism. Taking the example you stated - buying a costly equipment and then not using it because running cost is high is patently stupid. The only reason the equipment would have been boat is because some army officers needed to build a more expensive villa for himself.
- Militarization of country comes at its own cost. Financial and otherwise. I am not too much in favor of the thing. People should have a right to choose whether to get trained or not.
- Having too many CCTVs also will need an infra that is too far a goal today.
The price of freedom is eternal vigilance. First thing, we need an effective legal system that can speedily tackle cases so that they dont span over lifetimes.
Scrap the current legal system, make lawyers super expensive that people just get afraid of approaching a lawyer to file suit against anybody. That will decrease cases and increase effectiveness.
Then maybe they can start tackling the infrastructure issue by installing CCTVs, etc.
Good post. Thought provoking.
Yes I agree that there should be a counter terrorism strategy that trickles down and impacts everyone. We cannot stop these kind of attacks without intelligence. Even as we adopt technology, coordinate intelligence analysis at the higher level, we should go and recruit more policemen and policewomen. And a simple thing like an effective police beat system coupled with an alert citizens would go a long way to detect more and more of these attacks early. if a policeman/policewoman makes a beat to every street atleast once a week keeps eye and ear open and alert citizens could communicate with them without fear it can be an effective check, is my opinion.
I dont think you meant militarization, did you? But military training is an interesting idea. Definitely atleast some kind of disaster response teams should be trained at the local level. One can look at stocking hospitals with enough blood, buffer stocks of medicines/equipments that would be needed when bomb blasts occurs, conducting trials etc. which can improve our response speed and save some lives if such incidents happen.
We urgently need doubling or trebling the existing police force.
India has around 140 cops for a population of 10,000( or is it one lac?) while global average is 270!
We live besides the global terror hub and also do have some internal fault-lines. More cops also mean better intelligence gathering. Nothing but efficient policing can prevent terror attacks.
India defeated terror in Punjab through police force only. High time we also do the necessary police reforms mandated by Supreme Court and strengthen the police force.
Post a Comment